What is the best pacifier for the breastfed baby? (updated 2021)

Babies who are used to breastfeeding they refuse to suckle pacifier that they don’t feel, look like breast nipple or has a breast nipple texture. What is the best pacifier for the breastfed baby?

pacifier for the breastfed baby

Pacifier for breastfeed baby Comparison

 NameImageMaterialshield shapeWhere to buy
1.Philips Avent SCF190/01 Siliconeround shapedBuy from Amazon
2.WubbaNub PacifierSiliconeround shapedBuy from Amazon
3.The First Years GumDrop Siliconebutterfly shapeBuy from Amazon
4.Joovy Silinoogie Pacifierssiliconebutterfly shapeBuy from Amazon
5.Natursutten Pacifiernatural rubber pacifierNatural Rubberround shapedBuy from Amazon
6.Nookums PacifierSiliconeround shapedBuy from Amazon
7.Dr. Brown’s HappyPaciSiliconebutterfly shapeBuy from Amazon

Pacifiers for breastfed babies are made to help the baby who suffers from nipple confusion or they struggle to switch from dummy to breast nipple.

These pacifiers have a round nipple that imitates mom breast nipple or bottle-feeding nipple.

Pacifier can be a lifesaver- If your baby is fussy even after feeding, cuddled, rocked, and when playing with her pacifier can help soothe such a baby.

Also, some babies still want to suck even after having their bottle full of formula or breast milk; pacifiers can be of help.

The pacifiers for breastfed babies are not only for breastfeeding babies but for any baby who is fed formula milk using a feeding bottle.

Before we provide the review of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies let’s learn the necessary information you need to know before buying one.

Top 7 best pacifier for breastfed baby

  1. Philips Avent SCF190/01 Soothie
  2. The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier
  3. Joovy Silinoogie Pacifiers
  4. Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci Silicone Pacifier
  5. Natursutten BPA-Free Natural Rubber Pacifier
  6. WubbaNub Infant Pacifier
  7. Nookums Paci-Plushies Elephant Buddies – Pacifier Holder 

What is a pacifier?

Pacifier is an artificial nipple that the baby can suck and is mostly used to calm a fussy baby.

As the name suggests they calm or soothe your little one.

A pacifier is an American English name so it is also known as the dummy in British English and Australian English, binky or soother in Canadian English.

What to consider when buying the pacifier for the breastfed baby

  • Right size

Your baby’s mouth size determines the right pacifier size.

Some brands have the age sticker on them which informs the right age the pacifier is made.

Most are classified in age as below six months(0-6 months) which is a small size, 6 to 18 months which is medium, and over 18 months which is a large size.

It is advisable to always check the right age on the manufacturer’s sticker.

  • Material made for

Pacifier is made of materials such as rubber, plastic, or silicone. Some babies can have allergies to some of these materials so make sure you buy the pacifier that is comfortable with your baby.

Silicone is considered the best for the first six months but once they start to teether, you can change to rubber.

The material should be BPA-free.

Also, the material should be easy to clean.

Related articles:

  • The pacifier should have a shield

A shield is a part that prevents the baby from suckling the whole pacifier into her mouth.

It has to be large enough about 1.5inches or bigger to avoid a choking hazard.

The shield shape is either a butterfly or a round shape.

Butterfly style is a unique contoured shape constructed such that it fits the baby’s face while staying clear off the baby’s nose.

Also the butterfly shape curves away from the baby’s face providing ample space for little nose and cheeks.

Round shape- is the circular style that gently touches the nose, more closely simulating breastfeeding.

  • Types of pacifiers
orthodontic pacifier vs round shaped pacifer

There are different types of pacifiers in the market. These include:

 Round shape nipple 

The same as the feeding bottle. They imitate breast nipples and are suggested as the best pacifiers for breastfed babies.

The round shape pacifier helps the baby who suffers from nipple confusion or they struggle to switch from dummy to breast nipple.

Orthodontic pacifier 

Orthodontic pacifier

This type has a nipple flattened at the bottom and a rounded top. Orthodontic pacifiers help reduce pressure on developing teeth. They are the best teething pacifiers.

An orthodontic pacifier is introduced when the baby has fully established good breastfeeding habits.

Pacifier for the breastfed baby reviews

Round shaped shield

Round shaped shield pacifiers

  1. Philips Avent SCF190/01 Soothie


  • Material-silicone
  • Design –one-piece design
  • Age -0-3 months
  • Color- 6

The Philip Avent soothie is the choice of over 2000 hospitals in the USA.

Made of hospital-grade silicone, without any detachable taste and odor making the Philip Avent pacifier acceptable to your baby. It is also latex and BPA-free.

The nipple is durable, smooth, resists becoming discolored, misshaped, and sticky.

It has a safe, one-piece design that adheres to the American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines for newborns.

To sterilize the pacifier steams sterilize or boil for five minutes. It is also dishwasher safe.

In the box are two soothie pacifiers.

How to take care of Avent pacifier

The pacifier should be replaced after four weeks of use.

Do not leave the pacifier near the source of heat, direct sunlight, or leave in sterilization solution for the recommended time this may weaken the nipple.

Put in the boiling water before first use. Allow it to cool and squeeze excess water trapped in the pacifier.

The pacifier can be cleaned using warm water; do not use abrasive cleaning agents or antibacterial cleaners as this may cause the pacifier to crack.

Check the nipple by pulling if any sign of damage or weakness throws the pacifier away.

butterfly-shaped shield pacifier

Butterfly-shaped shield pacifier

  1. The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifier


  • Material-silicone
  • Design –one-piece design
  • Age -0-3 months
  • Color- 2

The first year’s pacifier is a one-piece design made of latex-free silicone material. The material is durable, lightweight, and easy for your little one to handle.

Available in a variety of colors and its unique contoured shape is designed such that it fits the baby’s face while staying clear off the baby’s nose.

It comes in two packs so you will have a spare in case the other one is dirty.

This brand efficiently works with most pacifier attachers and is sized for babies from 0-3months.

  1. Joovy Silinoogie Pacifiers


  • Material-silicone
  • Design –one-piece design
  • Age -0 months and above
  • Color- 6

The Joovy Silinoogie Pacifiers is designed for newborn babies and above.

Made of silicone material which is BPS, BPA, Latex, and Phthalate free, resistant to absorbing tastes, odors, or stickiness.

The one-piece design is easy to clean, and the handles allow pacifier straps to be attached.

Featuring a curved shield making the pacifier provides a comforting fit under the baby’s nose and helps minimize any pressure on the baby’s face while sleeping. It also has a nipple-shaped design that soothes the baby while delivering easy transitions between Boob bottles, mom’s breast, and pacifier.

The package has 2-pacifier which is dishwasher safe and available in various colors.

  1. Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci Silicone Pacifier


  • Material-silicone
  • Design –one-piece construction
  • Age -0+ months
  • Color-2

One-piece construction pacifier is made of silicone which BPA free, lightweight and soft. The material is dishwasher and sterilizer safe.

Dr. Brown’s pacifier is shaped like a nipple so introducing it to your baby is more comfortable. It also has a butterfly-shaped shield that curves away from the baby’s face for comfort, providing plenty of room for little noses and cheeks.

It comes in different colors, suitable for 0+ months, two and three-pack.

Munchkin Latch Natural Shaped Pacifier 

Natural Rubber Pacifier
Natural Rubber Pacifier
  1. Natursutten BPA-Free Natural Rubber Pacifier
natural rubber pacifiers for breastfed babies


  • Material-natural rubber
  • Design –one-piece design
  • Age -0 -12 Months Plus
  • Color-

The Natursutten pacifier is made of natural rubber which is soft and has no BPA, phthalates, or chemical softening agents.

Uniquely one-piece design with no joints or cracks where dirt and bacteria can hide meaning it is easier to clean your pacifier using a hand, warm water, and mild soap (never clean using a dishwasher).

It is available in two shield styles either circular and butterfly shapes (check the difference above).

Like the toothbrush, it is recommended to replace the pacifier every 6 to 8 weeks. Also, the pacifier should be replaced if the nipple sticks together when pressed and start peeling.

The package has two pacifiers, heavy use of pacifiers results in nipples to expand so Natursutten recommends the use of two pacifiers at once and alternating them.

It comes in different sizes small 0-6months, medium 6-12months, and large from 12 months and above.

Note: When you open you may notice the rubbery smell that’s perfectly natural rubber.

Sterilize the pacifier before using it for the first time.

The pacifier may turn whitish after boiling five minutes but don’t worry it will come back to its original color after a few days.

LARGE 12 months Up, Natursutten BPA-Free Natural Rubber Pacifier, Rounded Nipple 12 mo up 

MEDIUM 6-12 months, Natursutten BPA-Free Natural Rubber Pacifier, Rounded Nipple 6-12 mo

pacifier with the stuffed animal
Pacifier with the stuffed animal
  1. WubbaNub Infant Pacifier


  • Material-silicone
  • Design –one-piece design
  • Age -0-6 months
  • Color- various

The WubbaNub infant pacifier is an original pacifier and plush animal combination which is made of a Soothie medical-grade silicone pacifier. The material is Latex-free, BPA, PVC, and Phthalate free.

The Plush animal makes finding a lost pacifier easy.

Designed using one-piece construction makes WubbaNub pacifier durable, functional, and stylish. Also, the patented design makes it easier for the baby to grasps.

It is recommended from newborn through six months but not for babies with teeth and in the teething stage.

  1. Nookums Paci-Plushies Elephant Buddies – Pacifier Holder 


  • Material-silicone
  • Design –
  • Age -0-6months
  • Color-

This brand is made of medical-grade silicone which BPA, Latex, and Phthalate free. Also, the material is machine washable.

Nokum pacifier comes with Paci-Plushies Pacifier Holders which helps to find the lost pacifier easily or without stress. The Paci-Plushies animals are made of polyester which machine washable.

Also, the Paci-Plushies Pacifier Holders have a flexible Hug Ring that attaches to other brands of pacifiers such as mam, Nuk, Avent, and others that have button shields. Also, the ring can be used as a teether and is filled with purified water that you can refrigerate and chill to soothe tender gums.

It is made of a huggable design which is sized for a little hand to maneuver the pacifier independently.

Best pacifiers for breastfed babies with the thermometer
Best pacifier for breastfed baby with the thermometer

Dorel Juvenile Group Safety 1st Comfort Check Pacifier Thermometer 

Pacifier accessories

Advantages of baby pacifier

  • The pacifier helps calm a fussy baby.
  • Pacifier help baby fall asleep quickly
  • It can be used to soothe during the teething period. Source 
  • Babies who use a pacifier during bed or naptime reduce the risk of sudden infant death (SIDs). 
  • If your child sucks the thumb and you want her to stop you can use a pacifier. Also, it helps if you’re going to keep the child from developing the habit of suckling the fingers.

Disadvantages of pacifier

The front top and bottom teeth become misaligned.

  • Pacifiers can cause the spread of germs to your baby.

For instance, when the pacifier falls from the baby’s mouth to the dirty ground and the baby picks it and returns to the mouth it can spread germs to the baby.

Also, when you are on the go and the pacifier falls on the dirty ground most moms wipe it using the saliva and return it to the child’s mouth.

If you are sick, you have a high chance to spread bacteria to your child. Source.

To avoid your baby falling on the ground you can buy a pacifier clip to hold your baby binky.

In case the pacifier falls on the ground you can wipe with pacifier wipes, burp cloths, or bib and pop it back to the baby’s mouth. 

  • Getting off the habit becomes hard

Most parents use the pacifier to soothe the baby but stopping the habit becomes hard. It can take more months to break the habit.

  • Using a pacifier for too long may cause an ear infection. Find more details here.
  • Early introduction of a pacifier can result in poor breastfeeding,

Tips you should know before introducing a pacifier to your child

  • Do not introduce pacifier if your baby is having a problem such as gaining weight or poor breastfeeding.
  • Do not introduce pacifiers before your child has established breastfeeding routine or your milk supply is well established.
  • Wait for about 4-6 weeks before you introduce a pacifier,
  • Make sure the pacifier is always clean. Wash them regularly you can use the dishwasher and then sterilize. You can put them in boiling water for sterilization.
  • Do not give your baby pacifier when hungry.
  • If your baby does not like pacifier do not force it
  • If the pacifier falls off when sleeping does not force is back again.
  • Choose a one-piece construction pacifier but not a multiple-piece pacifier. The one-piece is made of a single piece of material which is hard for the part to tear therefore reduces the risk of choking.
  • Multiple piece pacifier consists of different parts (shield, nipple, and ring) each part is manufactured and combined separately. The part can easily come apart causing a choking hazard.
  • Do not coat the pacifier using sugar substance so as your baby may get used to it or forcing your baby to use. Using sugar substances may lead to cavities.
  • Do not use a pacifier as a food replacement or tool to delay feeding time.
  • Do not tie pacifier on the baby crib or stroller the baby might strangle using the cord or ribbon but you can use pacifier clip with short ribbons/straps/string to hold the soother.
  • Do not use a pacifier for a longer time. Limit the time your baby use pacifier and always find other ways to soothe your baby.
  • Most expert advice to get rid of the pacifier once the baby reaches 12 months.

Pacifiers for breastfed babies frequently asked questions

How do you know your baby needs a pacifier?

Babies are not able to communicate what they want we are left guessing according to their behaviors.
In the same case as the pacifier, you check the behaviors of your baby
You can know your baby needs a pacifier with behaviors like
Your baby will continue sucking the breast without the intent of drawing milk,
Suckling empty feeding bottle
Suckling toys or fingers.
If your baby spits out the pacifier and continues to be fussy, she might be hungry or is suffering from something.

What is the right age to introduce a pacifier?

According to a specialist you are supposed to introduce a pacifier after four weeks or when your baby is breastfeeding well, and the mom’s milk supply is well established.
This time is around four weeks for most babies.

When is the right age to stop using a pacifier?

Prolonged use of a pacifier can affect your child’s health.
It is recommended to stop using pacifiers from one year to around two years old.

When should you replace the pacifier?

Most parents are fond of not replacing baby products, but when it comes to the pacifier, it can pose a safety risk.
You need to replace the pacifier when
The nipple is torn.
If there is a broken part
When the pacifier is discolored
Nipple sticks together when pressed and start peeling
Replace the pacifier after every 6 to 8 weeks of use

Is a pacifier safe on babies?

Pacifier is safe for babies they offer benefits such as help prevent Sudden infant death, help soothe your fussy baby, and more.

Is it safe for babies to sleep with a pacifier in their mouth?

Yes, it is safe for babies to sleep with a pacifier in their mouths.
In case it falls off the baby’s mouth you should not pop it back.

Can pacifier choke the baby?

One of the things you should check before buying a baby pacifier is whether it has a shield.

A Pacifier should have a shield that is 1.5 inches or bigger to avoid a choking hazard.

The shield prevents the baby from suckling the whole pacifier.

Also, choose a pacifier made of one-piece construction and not multiple-piece construction.

Multiple piece construction each part is combined and manufactured separately which is easy to come apart and cause a choking hazard.

A one-piece construction pacifier is made of a single material that is hard to come apart.

Rounded nipple or orthodontic pacifier which is the best

Rounded nipple pacifier is for Babies who are used to breastfeeding they refuse to suckle pacifiers that they don’t feel, look like breast nipple, or has a breast nipple texture.

An orthodontic pacifier can be introduced after the baby gets used to the pacifier. They are best used when your baby starts teething, therefore, help reduce pressure on developing teeth

Are pacifiers bad on the baby tooth?

Pacifiers are bad on the baby teeth if used for a longer time.

That’s why expert advises parents to get rid of pacifiers once the baby is age one to two years to help prevent tooth misalignment.

Also, an Orthodontic pacifier will not interfere with jaw development and reduces pressure on developing teeth.

Bonus Video for pacifier safety and hygiene

Pacifier is a great way to soothe your baby.

Hoping our review of the best pacifier for a breastfed baby will help find the right binky for your baby. 

1 thought on “What is the best pacifier for the breastfed baby? (updated 2021)”

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: